Why reports of agriculture’s demise are greatly exaggerated

Farming activities comprise more than half of the total average monthly income for agricultural households, as per the latest survey by Nabard

Bengaluru/New Delhi: Farmers may be looking for alternative avenues of income, but it is too soon to write off the significance of agriculture in rural India, data from the recently released Nabard All India Rural Financial Inclusion Survey (NAFIS) shows.

An initial reading of the survey findings seems to suggest that earnings from farm-related activities—cultivation and livestock rearing—contributed just 43% to average monthly income of agricultural households in 2015-16, suggesting the growing importance of non-farm sectors in rural India.

However, disaggregated data on wage earnings of these households, accessed by Mint from Nabard, shows that about 40% of the wage earnings of these families came from working as farm hands; for non-farm households this ratio is about 25%.

So when wages from working as farm hands are added to earnings from agriculture, the contribution of farming activities to average monthly earnings of agricultural households rises to 57%, showing that bulk of their earnings is still farm-dependent.

The survey defines an agricultural household as one that received at least ₹5,000 as the value of produce from agricultural activities such as cultivating crops, horticulture, plantation, animal husbandry, poultry, fishery, etc, and which has least one member self-employed in agriculture.

A comparison with a similar survey carried out by the National Sample Survey Office (NSSO) in 2012-13 shows a decline in share of cultivation and livestock rearing in average incomes of agricultural households: from 60% in 2012-13 to 43% in 2015-16.

However, we need to keep in mind two big caveats while comparing the two surveys. One, the NAFIS survey is based on a stricter definition of agricultural household (NSSO’s threshold of income from agriculture was lower at ₹3,000), and a wider definition of rural areas.

Second, the NAFIS survey provides data for 2015-16, one of the worst drought years in recent memory. 11 states declared a drought that year, and about half of India’s districts received deficit rains even as production of food grains fell to a five-year-low. This means income from farming was depressed by nature that year.

The fact that farm incomes comprised 57% of overall incomes of agricultural households despite a drought only reinforces the importance of the farm economy in rural India. Agricultural households accounted for 58% of all rural households, data from the 2012-13 NSSO survey shows.

“A key takeaway from the Nabard survey is that for an agricultural household, the earnings from cultivation and wages are the two most important sources... this dependence on wages despite the slow growth in wages shows the crisis in rural India,” said Himanshu, associate professor of economics at Delhi’s Jawaharlal Nehru University. The NAFIS data also shows that 13% of agricultural households had only a single share of income, while 50% of them had two sources of income. Among non-agricultural households, most households (79%) depended on a single income stream.

Newsletter

Price of goats has gone up due to lack of supply in Kannivadi goat market

As farmers are not keen to sell the goats at the Kannivadi goat market, the arrival of goats has come down for the last...

Tomato prices fall sharply in Udumalpet - produce indiscriminately thrown on the road

Tomato prices were sold at Rs 200 per kg a few months ago. Now that the price of tomatoes has fallen drastically due to...

Tomatoes sold at Rs 6 per kg in Palladam - Farmers put veil on their heads and express anguish

Farmers in Tirupur district are suffering as tomatoes were procured at just Rs 6 per kg at the Palladam uzhavar santhai....

TNAU's Dept. of Plant Pathology hosts one-day training on 'Spawn Production and Mushroom Cultivation' in Coimbatore

Over a 100 beneficiaries from Kongunadu Arts and Science College in Coimbatore participated in the training which was pr...

Coimbatore TNAU observes Parthenium Awareness Week

Dr.M.K.Kalarani, Director (Crop Management), TNAU, Coimbatore has inaugurated the Parthenium awareness campaign at TNAU...

TNAU conducts Training on Preparation of instant Foods

Two days training on “Preparation of instant Foods” will be held at Centre for Post Harvest Technology, Agricultural...